Categories: MUMBAI UNIVERSITY IDOL NOTES

Meaning of Development and Theories of Modernization

Meaning of Development and Theories of Modernization

Hey Mumbai University SYBA IDOL students!  Today, we’re diving into the fascinating world of Sociology Of Development , exploring  about – “Meaning of Development and Theories of Modernization“. 

We will begin by discussing the basic concepts of social change, evolution, growth, and development. These terms may sound similar, but each has a unique meaning. Understanding these differences is important to get a clear picture of how society moves forward.

Next, we will explore the relationship between growth and development. While both are signs of progress, we’ll see how they are connected and also how they are different when we study them in the context of society.

We will then focus on the meaning of development and look at various theoretical approaches under modernisation theory. These theories help us understand how different countries and societies become modern or developed over time.

Lastly, we’ll study the contributions of some well-known thinkers to the theory of modernisation. These include Daniel Lerner, Hoselitz, W.W. Rostow, David McClelland, Everett Hagen, and Neil Smelser. Each of them has given important ideas about how development happens, and we will discuss their views in a simple and easy-to-understand way.

So, SYBA IDOL Mumbai University students, get ready to unwrap the “Meaning of Development and Theories of Modernization” with customized IDOL notes  just for you. Let’s jump into this exploration together

Follow Us For More Updates

Answer the following:-

Question 1 :- Write the Introduction to Infrastructure and Important Constituents of Infrastructure

Introduction:      

      Understanding human society requires us to study how societies transform over time. These changes shape our lives, cultures, economies, and political systems. Sociologists have developed several concepts to explain these transformations—namely social change, evolution, growth, and development. Each of these terms helps us understand different aspects of how societies progress or modify themselves. Although these ideas are interconnected, they each have specific meanings and implications. Analyzing these core concepts allows us to grasp how societies evolve and adapt in the course of history. This understanding is essential for sociologists, policymakers, and anyone interested in social progress and change.

1. Social Change:

         Social change refers to any significant alteration over time in the behavior patterns, cultural values, norms, and social structures of a society. It indicates that society is not static; it keeps evolving with new ideas, practices, and organizations replacing or modifying old ones. For a change to be considered ‘significant,’ it must have long-lasting effects and impact the way society functions.

   Causes of Social Change:

  • Contact with other societies (diffusion of ideas and practices)
  • Population growth and demographic changes
  • Movements based on ideology, politics, or economics
  • Technological innovations and discoveries

Examples: Historical examples include the Industrial Revolution, the abolition of slavery, and the feminist movement. These brought profound, lasting changes in societal structures, values, and ways of life.

2. Evolution:

        Evolution in sociology refers to the gradual process by which societies change from simple to more complex forms. It is based on the idea that societies naturally progress and develop over time through a series of stages. Sociologists borrowed this concept from biology, comparing societies to living organisms that grow and mature.

   Features of Social Evolution:

  • Societies develop in a unilinear manner, often from primitive to advanced stages.
  • Early theorists like Comte, Spencer, and Durkheim believed societies follow a fixed path of development.
  • It sees social progress as positive and beneficial for society.

   Theories of Evolution:

  • Comte believed in three stages: theological, metaphysical, and positive.
  • Spencer compared societies to organisms, evolving from military to industrial stages.
  • Durkheim emphasized increased division of labor and social solidarity.

Note: However, some theorists believe multiple paths of development are possible (multilinear evolution).

3. Growth

      Growth usually refers specifically to economic expansion—the increase in the production of goods and services in a society. It is a quantitative measure and often expressed in terms of GDP or national income. Growth is an important aspect of development but by itself does not necessarily mean social progress.

   Characteristics of Growth:

  • Focuses mainly on material and economic aspects.
  • Often measured in terms of increased output, income, and consumption.
  • Does not automatically translate into social benefits like better education or health.

   Limitations: Growth can be uneven, and focusing only on economic expansion can neglect social inequalities and environmental issues.

4. Development:

        Development is a broader concept than growth. It involves a comprehensive change in a society that improves the social, economic, political, and cultural well-being of its members. It is a multidimensional process that includes structural change, human progress, technological advancement, and social justice.

   Characteristics:

  • It is a positive process aimed at improving human lives.
  • It involves reorganization and reorientation of the entire system.
  • Development includes economic growth but also emphasizes education, health, equality, and overall quality of life.

   Types of Development:

  • Economic development (improvement in income levels)
  • Social development (better education and health)
  • Political development (more participation and rights)
  • Cultural development (preservation and growth of cultural identity)
Conclusion:

     The concepts of social change, evolution, growth, and development are central to understanding how societies change and progress over time. Social change describes any significant alteration in social life, while evolution refers to a gradual and often unilinear progression from simple to complex societies. Growth primarily focuses on economic expansion, whereas development encompasses broad improvements in human welfare and social conditions. These concepts are interconnected; growth can be a component of development, and social change often results from evolutionary processes. Recognizing and analyzing these concepts help us understand not just how society changes, but also why change occurs and what it aims to achieve. They provide important insights into managing social progress for the future.

Question 2 :- Examine the interrelation between growth and development

Introduction:      

         In the study of societies and economies, the concepts of growth and development are fundamental to understanding how nations progress and improve the lives of their people. While these terms are often used together, they have different meanings and implications. Growth mainly refers to an increase in the size of the economy, such as more production, income, or wealth. Development, on the other hand, is a broader idea that includes not only economic progress but also improvements in social, political, and cultural aspects that lead to a higher quality of life for people. Understanding how these two ideas are related helps policymakers and sociologists plan strategies for effective and sustainable progress. The relationship between growth and development is complex but very important, as one often influences the other in various ways.

1. Growth as a Foundation for Development
  • Economic Growth as Necessary for Development: Growth creates more resources, money, and wealth in a country. This extra wealth can be used to invest in health, education, infrastructure, and other areas that improve people’s lives.
  • Increased Income and Resources: When a country’s economy grows, more jobs are created, and incomes rise. Higher incomes help people afford better food, health care, and education, which are vital for social development.
  • Example: An increase in industrial output (growth) can provide funds for building hospitals and schools, which are essential for the overall progress of society.
2. Growth Alone is Not Sufficient for Development
  • Limitations of Growth: While growth increases income and wealth, it does not automatically improve the social or political conditions of a country.
  • Inequality Issues: Sometimes, economic growth benefits only a small section of society, leaving others behind. This creates inequality and social discontent.
  • Example: A country might have high GDP growth but still face issues like poverty, unemployment, and poor health services, indicating that growth alone does not ensure real development.
3. Development Includes Growth but Goes Beyond It
  • Broader Scope: Development refers to improvements in education, health, equality, political participation, and overall quality of life.
  • Human Development: As per Amartya Sen’s idea, development is about expanding people’s freedoms, choices, and capabilities—what they can do and be.
  • Example: A country can have high economic growth but poor social services. True development means improving these services and ensuring that economic gains benefit all society.
4. The Interdependent Relationship
  • Growth Supports Development: Without economic growth, it is difficult to fund social and infrastructural improvements necessary for development.
  • Development Promotes Growth: When the social environment improves—such as through better education and health—people are more productive, which can boost economic growth.
  • Balanced Approach Needed: Sustainable development depends on nurturing both growth and social progress simultaneously.
5. Challenges in Linking Growth and Development
  • Unequal Growth: Growth that benefits only a few can hinder overall development.
  • Environmental Concerns: Rapid growth without regard to ecological sustainability can damage resources, affecting future development.
  • Political Stability: Growth needs to be supported by stable governance to translate into meaningful development.
Conclusion:

     Growth and development are closely connected but not the same. Growth provides the material basis for development by increasing economic capacity, but development encompasses a wider range of human, social, and political improvements. For true progress, both must go hand in hand—growth should lead to equitable and sustainable development, and development should foster further growth. Recognizing this interrelation helps countries plan better and ensure that economic gains translate into better lives for all their citizens.

Question 3 :- What is development? Examine the various modernisation theoretical approaches to understand development.

Introduction:        

        Development is a concept that describes how societies and countries improve over time. It is often seen as a process that brings positive changes in the lives of people. Traditionally, development has been associated with economic progress, such as increased wealth, higher incomes, and better infrastructure. However, it also includes improvements in social and political aspects like education, health, equality, and general well-being. The idea of development is important because it helps us understand how countries can move forward and improve the quality of life of their citizens.

Different theories have been developed over time to explain and promote development. One of the most influential sets of explanations comes from modernization theory. This approach views development as a process of transforming traditional societies into modern ones by adopting Western ways of life, culture, and technology. Understanding these approaches helps us see the different ideas about how societies should change and progress.

1. Development as a Process of Change
  • Development means a continuous process of positive change, where societies become more advanced in terms of economy, social justice, and culture.
  • It emphasizes transforming traditional societies that are often based on agriculture and local customs into modern, industrialized societies.
  • Development is not just about economic growth but also about improving living standards, education, healthcare, and political rights.
  • It involves changes in values, attitudes, and social institutions to adapt to new ways of living and working.
2. Modernisation Theory and Its Approaches

       Modernisation theory is one of the main ways to understand development. It was widely accepted in the 1950s and 1960s and is based on the idea that all societies go through similar stages of development, mainly inspired by Western countries. Here are some key approaches within modernization theory:

a) The Classical Modernisation Approach
  • This approach sees development as a natural and inevitable process where traditional societies evolve into modern ones.
  • It emphasizes adopting Western values, technology, and institutions such as democracy and capitalism.
  • It assumes that progress happens when traditional customs and beliefs are replaced by rational thinking, scientific knowledge, and urbanization.
  • The goal is for developing countries to copy Western models of progress for rapid development.
b) Rostow’s Stages of Growth
  • W. W. Rostow proposed a famous model that describes development in five stages:
  1. Traditional Society – based on agriculture and old customs.
  2. Preconditions for Takeoff – improvements in infrastructure and some industries.
  3. Takeoff – rapid industrial growth.
  4. The Drive to Maturity – diversification of industries.
  5. Age of High Mass Consumption – widespread wealth and consumption.
  • Rostow believed that countries could move from traditional to modern societies by following these stages step-by-step.
c) The Contributions of Daniel Lerner
  • Lerner focused on social and psychological changes in societies. He believed that modernization involves changes in attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors.
  • According to him, exposure to mass media and information helps people adopt modern values like individualism, education, and innovation.
  • His idea was that social change is central to economic development.
d) The Idea of Technological and Economic Diffusion
  • Modernisation theory also emphasizes the spread (diffusion) of technology, knowledge, and practices from developed countries to less developed ones.
  • This process helps countries catch up by adopting new methods in farming, industry, and governance.
3. Criticisms of Modernisation Theory
  • While influential, modernization theories have been criticized for being too western-centric and assuming there is only one way to develop.
  • They ignore local cultures, traditions, and specific histories of different societies.
  • Critics argue that developing countries do not simply follow a linear path from traditional to modern societies.
  • It also overlooks issues like inequality, environment, and social justice.
Conclusion:

     Development means positive and continuous change in a society, including economic, social, and political improvements. Modernisation theory provides a useful framework for understanding how societies can develop by adopting Western values, technology, and institutions. Concepts like Rostow’s stages of growth, Lerner’s social change model, and diffusion of innovations highlight the importance of progress through modern practices. However, these theories also face criticism because they sometimes ignore local cultures and the complexities of social change. Understanding these different approaches helps us see the various ways countries can achieve progress and the challenges involved in the development process.

Theories:-

Question 1 :- Daniel Lerner

Introduction:            

      In the study of modernization and development, many scholars have tried to understand how societies change and progress. Among these scholars, Daniel Lerner is a well-known figure who contributed significantly to the understanding of social change, especially in developing countries. His ideas focus on how societies transform from traditional to modern and highlight the role of communication, attitudes, and individual behaviors in this process. Lerner’s work is important because it shows that social change is not only about economic growth or technology but also involves changes in people’s thoughts, feelings, and outlooks. His study provides insights into how culture and media influence development, especially in Middle Eastern countries, and remains influential in sociology and communication studies.

1. Who Was Daniel Lerner?
  • Daniel Lerner was a sociologist and communication expert who studied social and cultural change in developing societies.
  • His major work, “The Passing of Traditional Society” (1958), examined how societies in the Middle East were changing as they modernized.
  • He focused on the relationship between media, education, and social attitudes that promote development.
  • His theories help us understand how people’s mindsets and values need to change for progress to happen.
2. Key Ideas of Daniel Lerner

   a) Modernization as a Gradual Process: Lerner believed that modernization is a slow, step-by-step process. Traditional societies, based on customs and old ways, gradually move toward modernity through exposure to new ideas and information. This process involves changing the way people think and act.

 b) Role of Mass Media: According to Lerner, mass media (such as newspapers, radio, television) is very important in spreading modern ideas. Media exposes people to new ways of life, education, and better opportunities. It helps break down traditional beliefs that may hold societies back from development.

 c) Development of a “Mobile Personality”: Lerner argued that in modern societies, individuals develop a “mobile personality.” This means they become rational, open-minded, and adaptable. Such people are better able to cope with change and are more willing to adopt new ideas. A “mobile personality” is essential for societal progress.

 d) Traditional, Transitional, Modern: Lerner classified people into three groups based on their attitudes:

  1. Traditional – people who stick to old customs.
  2. Transitional – those who are starting to change but still hold traditional views.
  3. Modern – individuals who fully accept modern ideas, values, and lifestyles.
  • The goal of modernization is to move more people from traditional and transitional to modern.

   e) Happiness and Awareness: He found that modern individuals tend to be happier, better informed, and more satisfied with their lives. Exposure to media and education makes them more optimistic about the future.

 f) Importance of Education and Communication: Education and communication help change attitudes. They enable people to understand the benefits of modernization and motivate them to change.

3. Significance of Lerner’s Ideas
  • His work shows that modernization involves shifting individual attitudes and psychological outlooks.
  • Media and education are tools that can speed up social change.
  • His ideas are useful for policymakers and development agencies working in the Third World to promote progress.
4. Limitations and Criticisms
  • Some critics say Lerner’s focus on media and communication ignores cultural differences.
  • It assumes that all societies want to become modern in the same way, which may not be true.
  • Critics also argue that social change is more complex and cannot be driven only by media exposure or education.
Conclusion:

    Daniel Lerner contributed valuable ideas to the understanding of social change and development. He emphasized that modernisation is a gradual process involving changes in attitudes, beliefs, and skills of individuals. Media plays a crucial role in spreading modern ideas, helping societies progress from traditional to modern stages. His concept of the “mobile personality” highlights the importance of rationality, adaptability, and openness to change for development. Despite some criticisms, Lerner’s work remains influential and helps us understand how communication and education can accelerate social transformation in developing countries.

Question 2 :- Hoselitz

Introduction:            

    In the study of social and economic development, many thinkers have tried to explain why some countries are wealthy and advanced while others are poor and backward. One of these scholars is Bert Hoselitz, an economist who focused on understanding the differences between developed and underdeveloped countries. Hoselitz believed that social organization and cultural values play a very important role in how a country develops economically and socially. His ideas look at how societies are structured, how they change over time, and what factors help or hinder development. His work is important because it shows that development is not just about money or technology but also about social behavior and cultural patterns. Exploring Hoselitz’s ideas helps us understand what makes some societies more successful in growth and which social habits or values might need to change for progress to occur.

1. Who Was Bert Hoselitz?
  • Bert Hoselitz was an economist who studied the social aspects of economic development.
  • He aimed to understand what social behaviors and values support or block the growth of countries.
  • His work in the 1950s contributed to the field of development sociology, which looks at how societies organize themselves.
  • He used the theory of Pattern Variables, developed by sociologist Talcott Parsons, to analyze differences between advanced and backward societies.
2. Main Ideas of Hoselitz

 a) Social Organization and Development: Hoselitz believed that the way a society is organized influences its ability to develop. Societies with flexible, open, and adaptable social systems tend to develop faster. Rigid or traditional social structures can slow down progress because they resist change.

  b) Pattern Variables: He relied on Talcott Parsons’ Pattern Variables, which are key choices societies and individuals make. These include: whether actions are based on tradition or personal choice, feelings or rules, and particularistic (favoring kinship or group ties) or universalistic (based on laws and standards) standards.

 c) Traditional vs. Modern Values: Traditional societies emphasize family ties, ceremonies, and obeying customs. Modern societies value individual achievement, rationality, and universal rules. Hoselitz argued that societies need to shift from traditional to modern values to promote economic growth.

 d) Attitudes and Values Needed for Development: Society’s attitude towards change, innovation, and education influences progress. Cultures that accept innovation and are open to new ideas are more likely to develop quickly. A mindset that encourages individual effort and scientific thinking is vital.

 e) Social Change and Development: Hoselitz saw social change as a necessary process for economic growth. Societies must gradually transform their social organization and values, moving toward flexibility and innovation. Resistance to change or adherence to old customs can hinder progress.

 f) Role of Education and Leadership: Education is key to promoting modern values and social change. Strong leadership can help shift social attitudes and encourage development.

3. Importance of Hoselitz’s Ideas
  • His work highlights that social behavior, culture, and values directly impact a country’s progress.
  • Development policies should consider social and cultural factors, not just economics or technology.
  • Encouraging cultural change and social reform is necessary for lasting development.
4. Criticisms of Hoselitz
  • Some critics say that his ideas overlook economic and political factors that also influence development.
  • Others argue that changing social values takes a long time and is difficult to implement.
  • Despite this, his emphasis on social factors remains important for understanding development.
Conclusion:

    Bert Hoselitz made significant contributions to understanding how social organization and cultural values affect development. His theory emphasizes that countries need to adopt modern attitudes—such as openness to change, individual effort, and rationality—for economic growth and social progress to happen. He believed that social change, driven by education, leadership, and cultural shifts, is essential for underdeveloped countries to catch up with advanced ones. Although some critics point out the difficulty of changing social values quickly, Hoselitz’s ideas remind us that development is not just about money or technology, but also about transforming social mindsets and behaviors.

Question 3 :- Rostow

Introduction:            

     In the field of economic development, various theories explain how countries grow and progress over time. One of the most influential ideas is introduced by Walt Rostow, an American economist and scholar. Rostow believed that all countries go through specific stages of development in a fixed, predictable way. His theory is part of modernization theory, which suggests that non-industrialized countries can develop and become prosperous by following the same path taken by Western nations like Britain and the United States. Rostow’s approach is based on the idea that economic growth occurs through a series of stages that each country must pass through in order to reach high levels of wealth and living standards. His model became very popular in the 1960s, especially among policymakers and development planners who wanted to understand how countries could develop faster.

1. Rostow’s Stages of Growth: An Overview
  • Rostow proposed that societies go through five distinct stages of economic development.
  • Each stage represents a step forward in industrialization, modernization, and increasing wealth.
  • This model shows a logical, step-by-step process that countries could follow to develop.
2. The Five Stages of Development

   a) Traditional Society

  • This is the starting point, where people mostly rely on subsistence farming, hunting, or gathering.
  • There is little technology and economic activity is limited.
  • Society is generally static, and little change is happening.
  • Examples include age-old communities with traditional customs and practices.

  b) Preconditions for Take-off

  • In this stage, external demand for raw materials starts economic change.
  • Countries develop more productive agriculture and begin to export cash crops.
  • Investments are made in infrastructure like canals, irrigation, and ports.
  • Society begins to move away from traditional values, and social mobility starts.
  • Technology begins to spread, and new industries are started.

  c) Take-off

  • This is a critical phase where the economy shifts from primary goods (like crops) to manufacturing industries.
  • Industries grow rapidly, especially textiles, clothing, and other goods for both local use and export.
  • Investment increases significantly, and society starts to modernize rapidly.
  • Society becomes more focused on economic growth and industrial activities.

 d) Drive to Maturity

  • Technology becomes more advanced and complex.
  • Multiple industries develop, including heavy industries and manufacturing.
  • Countries shift from investment-driven growth to consumption-driven growth.
  • Infrastructure like transport, communication, education, and healthcare improves.
  • Society adopts values and institutions of high-income countries.

 e) Age of High Mass Consumption

  • The economy becomes highly industrialized with a large consumer base.
  • Society focuses on buying and using consumer goods—like cars, appliances, and entertainment.
  • Basic needs are easily met, and disposable income rises.
  • Living standards improve significantly, and people enjoy a high level of comfort.
3. Key Features of Rostow’s Theory
  • The theory emphasizes that countries can follow a linear path toward development.
  • Development is seen as a process that necessarily involves change and modernization.
  • The model assumes that societies pass through these stages in a specific order.
  • It suggests that technological progress and capital investment are vital for moving from one stage to the next.
  • Rostow believed there was a universal pattern of development that all countries could follow if they adopted the right policies.
4. Critique of Rostow’s Model
  • Many critics argue that the theory oversimplifies development by assuming all countries can follow the same path.
  • It ignores social, political, and cultural differences that might affect a country’s ability to develop.
  • The model is criticized for its optimistic view that development is inevitable and linear.
  • In reality, many countries face obstacles like colonial legacy, political instability, or economic crises that prevent a smooth progression.
  • Also, the model does not account for the impact of global inequalities and dependency relationships.
Conclusion:
      Rostow’s theory provides a clear and structured way to understand how countries develop through five stages, from traditional societies to wealthy, modern nations. It highlights the importance of technological progress, investments, and social change. However, it is also criticized for being too simplistic and not considering real-world complexities. Despite its limitations, Rostow’s model remains an influential idea in development studies, encouraging countries to adopt policies that promote industrialization and modernization for sustainable growth.

Question 4 :- McClelland

Introduction:            

       In the study of development and progress of nations, psychologists and social scientists have explored various factors that influence a country’s growth. One important factor is the motivation of individuals within a society, particularly their desire for achievement. David McClelland, a renowned psychologist, developed a theory emphasizing the role of achievement motivation in economic and social development. According to McClelland, people’s personality traits, values, and attitudes towards success play a key role in shaping a nation’s progress. He believed that the need for achievement is a psychological trait that can be developed and cultivated within individuals, and this trait significantly impacts economic growth and development. His ideas have been influential in understanding how personal motivation can drive national development and modernization.

1. Concept of Achievement Motivation
  • McClelland defined achievement motivation as the desire to do something better, faster, or more efficiently, with less effort.
  • People with high achievement motivation tend to set challenging goals, take responsibility, and persist in difficult tasks.
  • This motivation influences individuals’ work ethic, ambition, and desire for success.
  • In societies where achievement motivation is strong, productivity, innovation, and growth tend to be higher.
  • McClelland believed that this personality trait could be nurtured through education, training, and cultural influences.
2. Importance of Achievement Motivation for Development
  • Achievement motivation is crucial for economic development because motivated individuals are more likely to work hard, innovate, and seek new opportunities.
  • Countries with a high level of achievement motivation tend to be more enterprising and competitive.
  • McClelland argued that societies that emphasize success, self-help, and competition foster this trait among their people.
  • The development of achievement motivation can lead to better individual performance, higher productivity, and overall national progress.
  • Therefore, fostering achievement motivation in people can be a key strategy for development.
3. How McClelland’s Theory Explains Development
  • He believed that cultural values and socialization influence whether people develop a strong need for achievement.
  • Children can be taught values that promote achievement by stressing the importance of self-help, competition, and success.
  • Countries that encourage individual effort, innovation, and persistent hard work tend to advance more quickly.
  • McClelland’s research showed that children and adults could develop higher achievement motivation through targeted training and encouragement.
  • For example, a study in India suggested that businessmen who received short training became more adventurous and efficient, showing the importance of motivation in economic activity.
4. Relation Between Achievement and Society
  • Societies vary in their levels of achievement motivation based on cultural, social, and economic factors.
  • Traditional societies often have fixed status and less emphasis on individual achievement.
  • External factors like social insecurity or challenges to the old elite can motivate people to adopt new values and become innovative.
  • When social conditions become insecure or uncertain, some individuals may strive to prove their superiority and succeed, which can push economic progress.
  • The desire for achievement also influences social mobility, changing traditional social roles, and creating new opportunities for growth.
5. Contribution of McClelland’s Ideas to Development
  • McClelland’s focus on psychological traits highlights the importance of individual motivation in development.
  • His theory suggests that fostering a culture of achievement can improve productivity and innovation.
  • Practical programs like training courses can help develop achievement motivation among entrepreneurs and workers.
  • Recognizing the role of personal ambitions and values can help policymakers design developmental strategies.
  • His ideas also connect psychological development with economic progress, showing that personality traits matter for a society’s growth.

Conclusion:

      McClelland emphasized that the desire for achievement is a vital factor in the development of nations. By understanding and nurturing this trait in individuals and society, countries can foster a climate of innovation, hard work, and progress. His theory suggests that psychological qualities and cultural values play a crucial role alongside economic and technological factors in determining a country’s development. Therefore, promoting achievement motivation can be an effective way to encourage economic growth and modernization in any society.

Question 5 :- Hagen

Introduction:              

        In understanding how societies progress and develop, psychologists and social scientists have studied various traits and motivations that influence growth. One such important figure is Hagen, who expanded on the ideas of McClelland, emphasizing the role of achievement motivation in economic and social development. Hagen believed that the level of achievement motivation among individuals in a society greatly influences its development path. In his view, it is not only economic factors or technological advancements that determine progress but also the psychological traits, especially the desire to achieve and succeed. He studied how social and cultural factors shape these traits and how they, in turn, impact economic development. Understanding Hagen’s theory helps us see how individual personalities and societal values work together to promote or hinder progress.

1. Role of Achievement Motivation in Society
  • Hagen focused on the idea that the motivation to succeed, called achievement motivation, is a key factor in development.
  • The desire for achievement leads individuals to work hard, innovate, and aim for better performance.
  • Societies with high achievement motivation tend to be more dynamic, competitive, and progress faster.
  • This motivation influences everything from education to business activities, encouraging people to improve their skills and seek new opportunities.
  • Hagen believed that achievement motivation is influenced by social conditions, cultural values, and personal experiences.
2. Social and Cultural Factors Influencing Achievement Motivation
  • Traditional societies emphasize fixed social roles and respect for elders, which might discourage individual achievement.
  • In such societies, people learn to accept their assigned status and may not strive to improve their position.
  • External influences like social insecurity or threats to the status quo can motivate people to develop a desire for achievement.
  • When social or economic conditions become uncertain, individuals may be driven to challenge old traditions and adopt new, more ambitious goals.
  • Cultures that promote competition, personal effort, and self-reliance tend to foster higher achievement motivation.
3. How Achievement Motivation Affects Economic Development
  • Hagen believed that achievement motivation is crucial for economic progress because motivated individuals are more likely to work hard, be entrepreneurial, and seek innovations.
  • Economic growth accelerates when people have the desire to succeed and improve their conditions.
  • Societies that encourage effort, persistence, and risk-taking tend to develop more quickly.
  • The motivation to achieve can lead to technological innovation, better productivity, and the opening of new markets.
  • In societies where achievement motivation is weak, progress tends to be slow, and development is hampered by complacency or a fear of change.
4. Development of Achievement Motivation in Society
  • Hagen pointed out that social conditions influence whether people develop a strong achievement drive.
  • In traditional societies, children learn to follow established norms; deviation from norms is discouraged.
  • When external influences like social upheaval or economic challenges occur, young people tend to adopt more innovative and entrepreneurial attitudes.
  • Increased competition and opportunities for success can motivate people to change their behavior and seek personal and social advancement.
  • Education, exposure to modern ideas, and progressive social policies can help foster achievement motivation among individuals.
5. Hagen’s Contribution to Understanding Development
  • Hagen’s work broadened the understanding that social and psychological factors are important for development, not just material or technological aspects.
  • His theory shows that motivation and cultural values directly impact economic outcomes.
  • Recognizing the importance of achievement motivation can help governments design better policies to promote productivity and growth.
  • Programs that encourage individual effort, entrepreneurship, and competitive spirit can help societies progress.
  • His ideas link psychological traits with societal development, emphasizing a holistic approach to growth.

Conclusion:
      To sum up, Hagen’s theory highlights that achievement motivation is a vital driver of social and economic development. Societies that nurture a culture of effort, ambition, and innovation tend to advance more rapidly than those that do not. External factors and social conditions play a significant role in shaping individual motivation, which ultimately impacts overall progress. Understanding Hagen’s ideas helps us see that development depends not only on material resources but also on the psychological and cultural traits of the people within a society.

Question 6 :- Smelser

Introduction:              

       In the study of social change and modernization, sociologists have tried to understand how societies develop and transform over time. One important thinker in this field is sociologist Neal Smelser. He focused on understanding how economic development affects society’s social structure, and how societies manage or face social disturbances during this process. Smelser believed that social change is often caused by a mix of technological, economic, and social factors. These changes are not always smooth or easy; sometimes, they create conflicts or disturbances within the society. Understanding Smelser’s ideas helps us see how societies experience growth, face challenges, and find ways to adapt and maintain social order.

1. Smelser’s View on Social Change and Development
  • Smelser thought that social change is an inevitable part of modernization.
  • He believed that as societies become more modern, they experience various social processes like urbanization, industrialization, and changing family roles.
  • Development involves society moving from traditional to more complex social and economic structures.
  • Societies progress through different stages, but this progress also creates tensions and problems.
  • Overall, Smelser saw social change as a natural process linked closely to economic growth and technological advancements.
2. The Major Processes of Social Change (According to Smelser)
  • Smelser identified four main changes that happen when societies modernize:

a) From simple to complex technology: Societies adopt new tools and techniques, which increase production and efficiency.

b) From subsistence farming to cash crops: Agriculture changes from producing mainly for family use to producing surplus for sale.

c) From animal and human power to industrialization: Societies move from manual labor and animal power to mechanized industries.

d) Urbanization: People move from rural areas to cities, leading to more urban populations.

  • These processes do not happen all at once but over different periods and at different speeds in each society.
3. Social Disturbances in Modernizing Societies
  • Smelser believed that rapid social change often causes conflicts and disturbances.
  • The main reasons for social disturbances include:

a) Clash of tradition and modernization: Traditional values and customs conflict with new ideas and ways of life.

b) Unevenness of structural change: Changes happen unevenly, creating gaps and inequalities within society.

c) Rapid industrialization: Fast development can cause social stresses, unemployment, and dislocation.

  • These disturbances can threaten social stability and create social problems.
4. Role of Integrative Mechanisms
  • To manage these disturbances, societies develop mechanisms that help integrate different social groups.
  • These mechanisms include laws, institutions, and social norms that promote social cohesion.
  • The success of social change depends on how well these mechanisms function.
  • Effective integration helps society maintain order during periods of change.
5. Society as a Self-Correcting System
  • Smelser saw society as a large self-correcting machine, where adjustments happen automatically to restore balance.
  • When social disturbances occur, society reacts through social institutions, political leadership, and cultural practices.
  • If these responses are strong enough, social order can be maintained despite rapid changes.
  • However, if disturbances are too severe or unmanaged, social order may break down.
6. The Impact of External Factors and Natural Events
  • Besides internal changes, external factors like wars, natural disasters, or economic crises can affect the pattern of development.
  • These events may slow down or accelerate social change, or create new challenges for societies.
Conclusion:  
    Smelser’s approach explains that social change in modern societies happens through various interconnected processes like technological advancement, urbanization, and economic shifts. These processes often create social disturbances, but societies develop mechanisms to cope with these tensions and maintain order. His theory helps us understand how societies adapt and grow in a complex and dynamic world, emphasizing the importance of social institutions and stability during periods of rapid change.

Important Questions:-

  • Write the Introduction to Infrastructure and Important Constituents of Infrastructure
  • Examine the interrelation between growth and development
  • What is development? Examine the various modernisation theoretical approaches to understand development.
  • Daniel Lerner
  • Rostow
  • McClelland
  • Smelser

 Important Note for Students:-  These questions are crucial for your preparation, offering insights into exam patterns. Yet, remember to explore beyond for a comprehensive understanding.

muidolstudysquad.com

Share
Published by
muidolstudysquad.com
Tags: CDOEidol notesMeaning of Development and Theories of Modernizationmuidolstudysquadmumbai universitymumbai university idol notesSYBA IDOL NOTES
2 weeks ago

Recent Posts

Techniques of Data Collection

Techniques of Data Collection Hey Mumbai University SYBA IDOL students!  Today, we’re diving into the…

1 week ago

Human Development Index

Human Development Index Hey Mumbai University SYBA IDOL students!  Today, we’re diving into the fascinating…

2 weeks ago

Dependency Theory and Neo Liberal Approach

Dependency Theory and Neo Liberal Approach Hey Mumbai University SYBA IDOL students!  Today, we’re diving…

2 weeks ago

Research And Development Services with reference to Education

Research And Development Services with reference to Education Hey Mumbai University SYBA IDOL students!  Today,…

1 month ago

Role of Services Sector in Indian Economy

Role of Services Sector in Indian Economy Hey Mumbai University SYBA IDOL students!  Today, we’re…

1 month ago

Recent Policies and Programs for Industrial Development

Recent Policies and Programs for Industrial Development Hey Mumbai University SYBA IDOL students!  Today, we’re…

1 month ago